November 19, 2026 — U.S. President Donald Trump has departed Shenzhen after a third bilateral meeting this year with Chinese President Xi Jinping, followed by an unprecedented trilateral meeting between Trump, Xi, and Russian President Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of the APEC Summit. ASPI experts Wendy Cutler, David Shullman, and Lizzi C. Lee share their takeaways below. Members of the media interested in interviewing Ms. Cutler, Mr. Shullman, or Ms. Lee should email [email protected].
Wendy Cutler — Senior Vice President, ASPI
Like their September meeting, Thursday’s Trump-Xi meeting was also high on atmospherics and short on substance. There were no apparent breakthroughs on the trade and investment front, nor on the trade truce. In the absence of a timely U.S. readout of the meeting, the Chinese readout is the basis for the following observations.
China continues to place great importance on framing the relationship as “constructive strategic stability,” calling out the United States when Beijing perceives that U.S. actions are escalatory. The Chinese readout does not specifically mention Nvidia developments but does send a warning shot about not taking actions that could disrupt this framing. Earlier in the week, Beijing said it was prepared to take countermeasures against the U.S. in response to Washington’s tightening of chip controls.
AI seems to be the one area where some progress has been made, with China affirming its concerns about safety and security and welcoming bilateral work. It’s unclear whether the AI dialogue’s first official meeting, to be led by Bessent and He, actually took place in Shenzhen and what the next steps might be.
No announcement was made regarding an extension of the trade truce, which expires on January 10, nor the Chinese agreement to export more critical minerals and rare earths or to buy more U.S. agricultural products beyond soybeans. In many respects, this is not surprising. We expect these discussions to continue in the lead-up to the next Trump-Xi meeting on the margins of the December G20 meeting.
Furthermore, there was no announcement regarding tariff reductions on the $60 billion worth of goods identified and published by the Board of Trade in September. Finally, the Chinese statement made no reference to the work, if any, of the Board of Investment.
U.S. leverage to get China to comply fully with the terms of the trade truce has been weakened further this week. Chinese dominance in the critical minerals sector has already impacted U.S. leverage. Now, with the two leaders’ relationship warming, it’s not at all clear that Trump will stand behind his negotiating team should they continue to press China to the point of jeopardizing the truce and the broader relationship.
David Shullman — Vice President, ASPI
The meeting between Xi and Trump delivered no major developments, but that itself was revealing, underscoring Xi’s continued prioritization of bilateral stability in the face of new U.S. technology restrictions, as well as a bet that his personal relationship with Trump is key to limiting tougher U.S. policies in the wake of the Nvidia scandal and the midterms.
That personal touch was apparent from the moment Xi hugged Trump upon his arrival at the airport, returning Trump’s gesture when Xi arrived in Washington in September and marking the first time Xi has personally welcomed a visiting leader on the tarmac as president.
Xi did not threaten retaliation for new U.S. restrictions on China’s access to advanced compute through offshore data centers announced on the day of the meeting, at least publicly, and the issue was not mentioned in China’s readout. Meanwhile, the readout did highlight that the two leaders again agreed to build a “constructive relationship of strategic stability” and that Trump agreed to develop an action plan to make the framework more concrete, with regular meetings on implementation planned over the next year.
China may still retaliate over the new compute measures, as its Commerce Ministry has threatened, and it remains unclear how China will respond if further U.S. measures restricting China’s access to advanced technology are announced in coming months.
For now, however, Xi appears to be tolerating the measures, betting that Trump’s personal commitment to stability can temper more adverse U.S. action and preserve China’s opportunity to reshape the terms of strategic competition during Trump’s remaining time in office.
The value for Xi of continued personal and productive ties with Trump was only underscored by the U.S. president’s participation in the trilateral meeting with Putin held right after their bilateral meeting. Not only was the meeting an opportunity for China to play the pivotal role of convening these three nuclear powers for the first time, but it allowed Xi, the principal benefactor of Putin’s nearly five-year-long war on Ukraine, to portray himself as a statesman bringing major powers together to discuss strategic stability and peace.
The trilateral was light on deliverables, as expected, but the optics of Trump validating coordination with China and Russia to shape global events and institutions was striking, given Xi and Putin’s public commitment to upending the U.S.-led global order.
Lizzi C. Lee — Fellow on Chinese Economy, ASPI’s Center for China Analysis
For Beijing, this trilateral meeting is a diplomatic highlight, with Xi hosting Trump and Putin at the same table, positioning China as a leader capable of convening and managing great-power relations. But the actual outcomes are mostly symbolic, and this is no “Yalta 2.0” moment. Beijing itself has little appetite for bloc politics or for assuming responsibility for conflicts beyond its control or outside its core interests.
Interestingly, the Chinese readout places emphasis on energy stability and the commitment to increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products, in addition to nuclear risk reduction, sovereignty, and noninterference.
Energy stability serves the interests of all three countries: lower costs for the U.S., export revenues for Moscow, and more predictable manufacturing costs for Beijing, which has benefited enormously from globalization and has worries about further disruptions to global supply chains. I think this is probably the most concrete outcome of the meeting. But obviously, we need to see more specifics on what exactly was agreed to and how it will work in practice.
On the Xi-Trump bilateral meeting, the interesting term is the agreement to develop an action plan for their “constructive strategic stability” framework. This reflects an understanding that both sides need to move beyond leader-level goodwill toward more regular coordination between the two governments and across their bureaucracies. But we have no details yet on what the plan actually covers, who will implement it, or the timeline, so that’s something to look out for.
Overall, Beijing understands that competition and rivalry are not going away. But it wants predictability more than anything else, especially as China’s domestic economy remains weak and the Party Congress is looming next year.
Don’t miss ASPI’s upcoming events: After Shenzhen: What Did Trump and Xi Achieve?
November 23, 2026 | 10:30–11:30 a.m. ET | Online
Join Asia Society for a virtual expert panel to unpack the takeaways of Presidents Donald Trump and Xi Jinping’s third expected meeting of 2026. The discussion will feature Wendy Cutler, Senior Vice President of ASPI; Jing Qian, Vice President, Co-Founder, and Managing Director of CCA; Lyle Morris, Senior Fellow on Foreign Policy and National Security at CCA; and Lizzi C. Lee, Fellow on the Chinese Economy at CCA. David Shullman, Vice President of ASPI, will moderate.