The Catholic Church is conducting a comprehensive study to understand the reasons behind early departures of priests from active ministry in the U.S., aiming to identify contributing factors and improve retention.
Washington, D.C. – A significant investigation is underway within the Catholic Church in the United States, focusing on the increasing trend of diocesan priests leaving active ministry shortly after their ordination. This study, funded by the Knights of Columbus and spearheaded by researchers at The Catholic University of America, seeks to uncover the personal, spiritual, and institutional factors that contribute to these early departures.
Bishops and church leaders have expressed concerns that a growing number of priests are abandoning their ministry during the formative years of their service. In response to these observations, the research team aims to analyze actual data to determine if these impressions hold true. “We wanted to find out whether there is any basis for this in the numbers and, if so, what factors might be contributing to it,” explained Sara Perla, a representative from The Catholic University.
Scope of the Research
The undertaking is ambitious, encompassing a quantitative assessment of the careers of diocesan priests ordained in the United States between 2006 and 2025. According to Jesuit Father Thomas P. Gaunt, executive director of the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA) at Georgetown University, around 9,000 priests were ordained during this period. The research team’s objective is to track the current status of each of these individuals.
“We have 9,000 names and we have to find out where each one is today,” Gaunt stated. The CARA team is meticulously compiling anonymized data from various sources, including publicly available information, diocesan clergy lists, and the Official Catholic Directory. A key challenge is differentiating genuine departures from other circumstances that can affect a priest’s status, such as death, medical leave, or temporary assignments elsewhere.
Engaging Former Priests
Identifying priests who have left the ministry is only part of the challenge; contacting them poses further difficulties. Diocesan obligations to protect individual privacy complicate matters, necessitating a sensitive approach to reach out to former priests about their experiences. This aspect of the research is vital, as many former priests may find the topic deeply personal and potentially painful.
The study incorporates an extensive qualitative component led by sociology professor Brandon Vaidyanathan, who oversees the university’s Institutional Flourishing Lab. The research team includes data scientist Stephen Cranney, sociologist Maureen Day from Villanova University, University of Virginia sociologist Joseph Davis, and Notre Dame doctoral researcher Caitlin Fitzgerald. They have already engaged several dozen former priests, who have agreed to participate in in-depth interviews lasting between 60 and 90 minutes. The initial response has exceeded expectations, with 61 participants expressing interest within just one week.
Insights into Departure Reasons
The interviews will delve into the complete journey of these men, exploring their backgrounds, sense of vocation, formation, ordination, experiences in ministry, and the eventual decision to leave. The eligibility criteria for participants stipulate that they must have been ordained after 2000 and departed from public ministry within ten years of ordination, with the knowledge of their bishop or religious superior. However, those formally laicized or removed through canonical proceedings, as well as those who left without their superior’s knowledge, are excluded from the study.
According to Father Gaunt, the reasons behind these departures vary widely. Some individuals conclude that the priesthood was not their true vocation and express peace with their decision. Others cite strained relationships with bishops or traumatic experiences that they are reluctant to revisit. These diverse narratives highlight the complexity of the issue, suggesting that the reasons for leaving cannot be attributed solely to personal, spiritual, or institutional factors.
Aiming for Constructive Outcomes
Understanding these varied experiences is central to the project. Vaidyanathan hopes that the findings will enable bishops and church leaders to identify warning signs and respond proactively to prevent issues from escalating. Additionally, he emphasizes the importance of allowing former priests to articulate their experiences in their own words, rather than relying solely on institutional statistics.
The research team stresses that the investigation is not intended to undermine the value of priestly life. Perla asserts that examining the factors contributing to departures should be complemented by a recognition of those who remain committed to their vocation despite its challenges. “Most Catholics want to support their priests, and a clearer understanding of the pressures they face could help identify practical ways to do so,” she noted.
Preliminary findings from the study are expected to be released in autumn 2027. By combining a nationwide analysis of ordination records with firsthand testimonials, the project aims to provide the Church with valuable insights into the reasons some priests struggle to remain in ministry, what could have been done differently, and how the experiences of those who leave can inform better support for those who continue in service.